The 2011 Foxconn Chengdu explosion: what happened and what managers can learn
A sourced case summary for readers studying operations, supply chain management and business ethics.
This address once held an infographic titled "iKill". This page is a new, independently written article on the same subject. It does not reuse that infographic.
On May 20, 2011, an explosion hit a polishing workshop at a Foxconn plant in Chengdu, China. The plant made parts for Apple products, including the iPad. The event became one of the best-known supplier safety cases in modern business teaching because it involved a famous brand, a contract manufacturer, a worker-rights group that had raised the issue first, and a later public response from the brand.
What happened
Reuters reported that production in parts of the Chengdu plant was suspended after three workers died and 15 were injured in a blast in a polishing workshop, where the casings of Apple's products are finished. The New York Times reported the same toll and said a preliminary investigation by local authorities pointed to combustible dust as the cause.
The numbers later changed. In its 2012 supplier report, Apple gave the Chengdu toll as four killed and 18 injured, according to Computerworld's coverage of the report. Early press figures and later company figures differ, so a case write-up should name its source and date.
The warning that came before
A Hong Kong group, Students and Scholars Against Corporate Misbehavior (SACOM), said that a report it published in early May 2011 had already pinpointed an aluminum dust problem in the polishing department at the Chengdu site (EE Times). That timeline is the core of the management question: a warning from an outside group existed before the blast, and the case asks how such warnings should be handled inside a large supply chain.
What Apple said afterwards
In January 2012, Apple said in its annual supplier report that the explosions at Foxconn's Chengdu plant and at a Pegatron subsidiary's plant in Shanghai (December 2011, 59 injured by Apple's count) were both caused by combustible aluminum dust. Computerworld reported that Apple said it had required suppliers to put anti-dust measures in place.
Apple's own figures are company statements. They are useful as a record of what the company acknowledged, not as an independent audit.
Questions for students of operations and ethics
- Who is responsible for safety at a supplier's plant: the factory owner, the brand that buys from it, or both?
- What does a brand do with a warning from an outside group when it has hundreds of suppliers?
- Which hazards are predictable from the production process itself? Fine metal dust from polishing is a known explosion hazard, as the dust experts quoted in the coverage noted.
- How should a company report casualty numbers while an investigation is still open?
- What does it cost to prevent a hazard compared with the cost of a stoppage, a brand crisis and human harm?
Why this belongs in business education
Case discussions like this one sit where supply chain management, operations, risk and ethics meet. If you are comparing online MBA programs, check each program's course catalog for operations, supply chain and ethics content rather than assuming it is included. Our directory does not rate programs on these topics.
Sources
- The New York Times, Explosion at Apple Supplier Caused by Dust, China Says (May 25, 2011)
- Reuters, Explosion at China iPad factory highlights lax safety (May 24, 2011)
- EE Times, Student group blames Foxconn for blast
- Computerworld, Apple confirms aluminum dust caused Chinese factory explosions (January 2012)